There
have been many great partnerships between actors and
directors over the decades, but it is hard to imagine
a more combustible and endlessly fascinating relationship
than the one between Werner Herzog and Klaus Kinski.
For 15 years, they challenged, inspired and tortured
one another joyously into creating some of the most
enduring and unique experiences of modern film. Herzog
has directed over 40 films, but his best-known work
forced him to confront his own evil twin, the demonic
Kinski.
Herzog's stormy relationship with the notoriously difficult
Kinski is the stuff of modern mythology. It has been
recounted, explained, and analyzed by both principals:
by the late Kinski (who died in 1991) in his autobiography
Ich brauche Liebe, one of the most vicious attacks on
the film business ever written, which has been withdrawn
for legal reasons -he referred to Herzog as "the
vermin", "this blowhard" and "a
miserable, hateful, malevolent, avaricious, money-hungry,
nasty, sadistic, treacherous, cowardly creep"-
and by Herzog in his 1999 documentary, "Mein liebster
Feind / My Best Fiend" - "Every gray hair
on my head I call Kinski" Herzog tells the camera.
The visionary German filmmaker and his muse and nemesis
worked together five times -no other director ever worked
with Kinski more than once- and driven by mutual feelings
of mistrust, hatred and affection, the two men channeled
these emotions into unforgettable tales of madness and
passion.
Together they made "Aguirre, der Zorn Gttes /
Aguirre: The Wrath of God" (1973), about a mad
conquistador in the Peruvian jungle; "Nosferatu
- Phantom der Nacht / Nosferatu the Vampyre" (1978),
inspired by Murnau's silent vampire classic; "Woyzeck"
(1979), about a 19th century army private who seems
mad to others because he sees the world in his own alternative
way; "Fitzcarraldo" (1982), about a man who
used block-and-tackle to pull a steamship from one Amazonian
river system to another; and "Cobra Verde / Slave
Coast" (1988), about a slave trader in Africa.
All of their collaborations, which resulted in the best
films for both of them, contain extraordinary images,
but the sight of Kinski running wild inside an army
of naked, spear-carrying amazons in "Cobra Verde"
may be the strangest.
Their battles were as legendary as their films. "It's
not easy to explain our relationship", Herzog once
remarked. "The only thing that counts at the end
is what you see on the screen." Kinski, prone to
irrational bursts of rage, would frequently throw tantrums
on the set, but Herzog was willing to endure these because
of the quality of the performance that would come afterward.
One legend has Herzog threatening Kinski at gunpoint.
It never happened. When Klaus Kinski wrote his savage
autobiography, accusing Herzog of all sorts of horrors,
few knew that Herzog himself contributed the filthiest
insults as a favor to his old friend. When they really
did fight, the screaming and threats could go on for
hours Two combative and brilliant egos. Five films.
One documentary to sew the legend together. The Festival
offers all this in a comprehensive retrospective, which
reveals new layers to Kinski's strengths as an actor,
Herzog's talents as a director, and the obsessive relationship
between the two men.
One of the most influential filmmakers in the New German
Cinema movement, Werner Herzog (real name Werner H.
Stipetic) was born in Munich on 5 September 1942. He
grew up in a remote mountain village in Bavaria and
never saw any films, television, or telephones as a
child. He started traveling on foot from the age of
14. He made his first phone call at the age of 17. Herzog
knew he wanted to be a filmmaker from an early age.
And after unsuccessful attempts to persuade a production
company to finance his films when he was still a teenager
in high school, he worked the nightshift as a welder
in a steel factory to raise money for his work. He finally
made his first film in 1961 at the age of 19. He has
studied history, literature and theatre, but hasn't
finished it. He founded his own production company in
1963. Since then he has produced, written, and directed
more than forty films, published more than a dozen books
of prose. He has staged several operas, besides others
in Bayreuth, Germany, and at the Milan Scala in Italy.
He has won numerous national and international awards
for his films.
Werner Herzog began attracting attention with his short
films of the mid-'60s, and his first feature, "Lebenszeichen
/ Signs of Life", in 1968. As a writer/director,
Herzog made a series of provocative, highly personal
films, including "Auch Zwerge haben klein angefangen
/ Even Dwarfs Started Small" (1970), the cryptic
desert journey "Fata Morgana" (1970), and,
perhaps his finest work, the stunning "Herz aus
Glas / Heart of Glass" (1976), in which he hypnotized
his actors to get properly somnambulistic performances.
The director cast Bruno S., a lifelong inmate of mental
institutions and prisons, to play a real-life man who
was raised in a dark basement in "Jeder fr sich
und Gott gegen alle / Every Man for Himself and God
Against All" (aka "The Mystery of Kasper Hauser")
(1975) and as an uncomprehending visitor to the United
States in "Stroszek" (1977).
A long and tumultuous collaboration with the notoriously
volatile actor Klaus Kinski produced Herzog's best-known
films of the 1970s: his conquistador drama "Aguirre,
the Wrath of God" (1972); his 1978 remake of F.W.
Murnau's "Nosferatu the Vampyre"; and "Woyzeck"
(1978), his adaptation of Georg Bchner's classic play.
Notorious for dragging his cast and crew to remote and
arduous locations, Herzog has made fewer feature films
since the '80s; his notable works of that decade include
"Fitzcarraldo" (1982) and "Cobra Verde"
(1987), both with Kinski.
Werner Herzog is also widely admired as a superb documentary
filmmaker for such works as "Land des Schweigens
und der Dunkelheit / Land of Silence and Darkness"
(1971), about the deaf and blind. During the 1990s,
in fact, much of his work has centered around documentaries,
whether playing himself in "Die Nacht der Regisseure
/ The Night of the Filmmakers", a 1995 piece featuring
directors such as himself, Leni Riefenstahl, and Wim
Wenders discussing the state of German cinema and the
New German Cinema; as the director and screenwriter
of 1997's "Flucht aus Laos / Little Dieter Needs
to Fly"; or as the director and partial subject
of "Mein liebster Feind / My Best Fiend",
his 1999 documentary about his infamous collaboration
with Klaus Kinski.
In addition to his directing and screenwriting work,
Herzog has acted in a number of films, perhaps most
memorably in Les Blank's 1980 documentary "Werner Herzog Eats His Shoe". The film was the result
of a bet Herzog once had with an American film student:
Herzog told the student -who was always talking about
making a film but never actually doing it- that if he
actually completed the film Herzog would eat his own
shoe. The student was Errol Morris, who would later
become well known for his documentaries such as "The
Thin Blue Line", "Fast, Cheap & Out of
Control", and "The Fog of War", and he
did indeed make his film. Having lost the bet, Herzog
made good on his promise, and the result was one of
the stranger moments in documentary history.
"I am not the Jesus of the official Church I
am not your superstar" once Klaus Kinski has said
to Herzog. Kinski may have denied divinity, but his
Olympian ego would have made even Nietzsche twitch.
Born on 18 October 1926, in Zoppot, near Danzig/Gdansk,
in the region of Silesia (German territory at the time,
but now part of Poland), his real name was Nikolaus
Gnther Nakszynski. He grew up in Berlin, was drafted
into the German army and spent much of World War II
as a British POW. The self-taught Kinski's theater career
began after the war, and he was considered as a brilliant
but -not surprisingly- "difficult" actor.
He quickly gained a reputation for his ferocious talent
and equally ferocious temper. He has once attacked a
theater critic, who had failed to praise him sufficiently,
with two hot potatoes and some cutlery. Even from his
youth, he was a monster with a monstrous talent.
As a teen, the feral Kinski was dragged in from the
street and into then 13-year-old Werner Herzog's life.
"I was playing in the courtyard of the building
where we lived in Munich", Herzog said, "and
I looked up and saw this man striding past, and I knew
at that moment that my destiny was to direct films,
and that he would be the actor". He learned early
about Kinski's towering rages. The budding actor actually
lived for several months in the same flat with Herzog's
family, and once locked himself in the bathroom for
two days, screaming all the while and reducing the porcelain
fixtures "to grains the size of sand". ''I
never thought anyone could rave for 48 hours",
Herzog reflected, remembering the incident.
After his cinema debut in "Morituri" (1948),
Kinski appeared in numerous films, showing complete
lack of discrimination as to their quality (a complete
filmography is almost impossible to establish), in which
he usually embodied eccentric villains. His collaboration
with Werner Herzog in the '70s and '80s marked Kinski's
breakthrough into "serious" cinema and established
his reputation as enfant terrible of European film.
Both manically extroverted and a tortured perfectionist,
Kinski thrillingly depicted a series of malignant, obsessive
and untameble characters film after film.
Klaus Kinski reconnected with Herzog years later for
the arduous production of "Aguirre, the Wrath of
God". Herzog had not grown into a prince either:
the very camera he was using for the film had been stolen
from film school. Kinski arrived on location from a
one-man stage show as a raving Jesus, completely immersed
in the part. He immediately threw a fit about the Peruvian
rain, shot at extras with a rifle, and had to be threatened
with death to keep him from fleeing the production.
Herzog and Kinski would work together four more times,
each would owe much of his own fame to the other, and
their love-hate relationship would become the stuff
of legend. Again and again, Kinski would produce masterly
and shocking performances, combining iron professionalism
with the ability to "lose control" unforgettably
on the screen.
It was perhaps appropriate that Kinski's last film
was also directed by Herzog. Kinsky arrived at the set
of "Cobra Verde" after writing, directing
(his debut) and starring in the bizarre film biography
"Kinski Paganini" (1988). And that, according
to Herzog, lead to immediate problems, as Kinski had
come to believe that he was Paganini, the Italian violin
virtuoso who was said to be possessed by the devil.
"He brought with him into my film an unpleasant
climate, something offensive, something that was alien
to me", Herzog would say later. By the last day
of shooting which, coincidentally, involved Kinski's
final scene (Cobra Verde dying in the surf) Herzog had
already decided that Kinski was beyond anyone's control
-including himself- and that they would never work again.
Four years later, on 23 November 1991, Kinski died of
an heart attack at his home near San Francisco. As Herzog
describes it, "He had spent himself. He burnt himself
away like a comet."
Both Herzog and Kinski were megalomaniacs, and both
men knew it. But at least they had a sense of humor.
"My Best Fiend" is the final touch chronicling
the tempestuous relationship between these two artists.
As its slyly punning title suggests, the 1999 documentary
is Herzog's tribute to his doppelganger, featuring bizarre
stories of Kinski's cowardice and courage, shyness and
savagery, artistic brilliance and terrifying ego. Herzog
jokes about his plots to murder Kinski, and remembers
how the native extras during "Fitzcarraldo"
offered to dispose of the volatile actor.
It is important to note that, despite the many trials
and tribulations that these two warriors of German cinema
put each other through over the course of their working
relationship, the end result was worth every struggle,
and now, so many years later, the lovers of cinema can
see the breadth of their accomplishment.
"There were times when Kinski would behave more
instinctively and noticed that he was going too far.
And in those moments, thank God, he became cowardly.
There was one occasion on the Rio Nanay, at the end
of the "Aguirre" shoot, and as usual when
he didn't know his lines properly, as so often, he was
looking for a victim. Suddenly he started shouting like
crazy, 'You swine!', meaning the camera assistant, 'He
was grinning!'. He told me I should fire him on the
spot, but I said 'No, of course I'm not going to fire
him, the whole crew would quit out of solidarity'. So
he just went and packed his things he was so absolutely
serious about leaving at once that he would just walk
off the set; he packed everything into a speedboat.
And I knew he'd broken his contracts 30, 40, 50 times
already. So I went up to him very calmly by the way,
I didn't have a gun, he just made that up later to cast
a better light on himself. So I went up to him and said,
'You can't do this, the film is more important than
our personal feelings and it's even more important
than us mere mortals. It's impossible to do something
like this. You can't do it.' I told him I had a rifle,
and he would only make it as far as the next bend in
the river before he had some bullets in his head the
last one would be for me." - Werner Herzog
|